Author |
Topic Search Topic Options
|
Deluxe247
Guest
Joined: December 02 2009
Location: Salt Lake City
Status: Offline
Points: 336
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Topic: Butterflies Posted: May 10 2010 at 1:21pm |
I'm considering getting a butterfly to help eliminate the last few remaining aptasia in my 55G reef. I know they're not considered "reef safe" but I've heard of lots of people using these fish to eradicate pest anemones. Any suggestions or advice on butterflies? The tank has mostly softies (xenia, mushrooms, zoos, GSP and kenya tree) and a couple of LPS (frogspawn and candy) and a LTA. Other fish include 2 occeleris, 2 small blue damsels, 1 yellow tang and 1 pajama cardinal. I have lots of LR and LS, a skimmer, 10G fuge and good cleanup crew for filtration. I'm concerned about overstocking if I add the butterfly.
Edited by Deluxe247 - May 10 2010 at 1:25pm
|
90G Mixed Reef
|
|
Mark Peterson
Paid Member
Joined: June 19 2002
Location: Murray
Status: Offline
Points: 21436
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 2:04pm |
I would never use a Butterflyfish without first trying manual eradication and Peppermint Shrimp. have you tried those? P. shrimp do so many more things for a reef and have no bad habits.
|
Reefkeeping Tips, & quick, easy setup tricks:www.utahreefs.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9244 Pay it forward - become a paid WMAS member
|
|
downhill_biker
Guest
Joined: February 28 2009
Location: West Jordan, UT
Status: Offline
Points: 2167
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 3:21pm |
Mark Peterson wrote:
I would never use a Butterflyfish without first trying manual eradication and Peppermint Shrimp. have you tried those? P. shrimp do so many more things for a reef and have no bad habits. |
Other than stealing food from corals...
|
Make sure you post your best pictures every month in our POTM forum.
|
|
Deluxe247
Guest
Joined: December 02 2009
Location: Salt Lake City
Status: Offline
Points: 336
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 4:27pm |
I have tried peppermints on 2 occasions before, and both times I believe they have fallen victim to my brittle star. I have also used Aptasia X with quite good results. The problem is just a few remaining aptasia that I can't reach with the syringe, or they're too quick at retreating into their holes. I guess another alternative would be to remove the rock they're on and use kalk paste (or can you put that on underwater?) I'd prefer not to remove any rocks for fear of killing other goodies on them. Not to mention, they're structurally integral to the reef. Anyway, I guess if I have to I have to.
|
90G Mixed Reef
|
|
tycallsky
Guest
Joined: January 05 2010
Location: Provo, Utah
Status: Offline
Points: 109
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 5:41pm |
Try using a Peppermint. if that doesn't work use Aptasia X or inject them with lemon juice. (I personally have not had luck with any of the above methods.) If that doesn't work, or if you would rather skip ahead to something that does work, use a Copperband Butterfly. They will make short work of your aptasia for sure. You don't have to worry about overstocking your tank. Trust me on that one. I do 15% water change every week, have a great skimmer, use a carbon bag, and have a 2inch substrate and modest LR. I currently keep 9 fish and 25 corals in my 28 gallon. I have not had problems with fish death or coral death. I had a problem with cyano but that was very short (because I got some crabs that eat it.) and my ammonia and nitrites test at 0 and my nitrate level is always 20< on the day of my water change. I personally believe that a Copperband would be lovely.
|
|
|
tycallsky
Guest
Joined: January 05 2010
Location: Provo, Utah
Status: Offline
Points: 109
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 5:43pm |
that is 20< pre-change not post-change.
|
|
|
Deluxe247
Guest
Joined: December 02 2009
Location: Salt Lake City
Status: Offline
Points: 336
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 5:55pm |
A copperband is the kind I was thinking of. I'll give it some thought. I think my problem is that I can only get the aptasia I can see and there are likely many more that are currently too small or hidden that are not only growing but reproducing. I was told the peppies would at least control the spread of aptasia since they mainly feed on the babies, but instead they became brittle star food.
|
90G Mixed Reef
|
|
tycallsky
Guest
Joined: January 05 2010
Location: Provo, Utah
Status: Offline
Points: 109
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 10 2010 at 5:59pm |
Yeah. Peps aren't very good. I have had three die because they would not eat the aptasia or any food I gave them. *shrugs* I'm sure other people have had success, but Mine died within a week. *i know it's not the water quality because I added a peppermint and a spotted mandarin at the same time and the mandarin lived.
good luck friend
|
|
|
Mark Peterson
Paid Member
Joined: June 19 2002
Location: Murray
Status: Offline
Points: 21436
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 12 2010 at 1:25pm |
Congrats tycallsky on making post number 100.
I would suggest we talk more about Peppermint Shrimp before all of you dismiss them. Peppermint shrimp are great. Butterflyfish are a headache. I may be a little gruff sometimes but I know what I'm doing. I have been at this hobby intensely for 17 years. Are you ready to learn?
|
Reefkeeping Tips, & quick, easy setup tricks:www.utahreefs.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9244 Pay it forward - become a paid WMAS member
|
|
tycallsky
Guest
Joined: January 05 2010
Location: Provo, Utah
Status: Offline
Points: 109
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 12 2010 at 1:46pm |
Teach me Sensei. I am ready.
|
|
|
Deluxe247
Guest
Joined: December 02 2009
Location: Salt Lake City
Status: Offline
Points: 336
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 12 2010 at 4:46pm |
Mark, I appreciate your willingness to help. I am interested in any ideas you can provide regarding peppermints since I would much rather avoid risking the survival of my other corals to a hungry butterfly. I definitely haven't made any decisions yet, so please fire away. My main concern with the peppermints is that both times I've had them they have fallen prey (I think) to my brittle star. Unless there's some other factor contributing to their speedy demise, I can easily throw the star into my sump so it can't get to the peppermints. Let me know what your thoughts are.
|
90G Mixed Reef
|
|
Mark Peterson
Paid Member
Joined: June 19 2002
Location: Murray
Status: Offline
Points: 21436
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: May 13 2010 at 12:06am |
Well first off, it wouldn't be a bad idea to remove the suspect Brittle Star, though I would guess a <50% chance that it was the culprit.
There are several aspects to note.
1- Some shrimp sold as Peppermint are not and don't do much for Aiptasia. At certain seasons the most reliable Aiptasia eating P.Shrimp are available from Florida.
2- If the P.Shrimp is not hungry and the owner feeds too well, the P.Shrimp will not touch the Aiptasia. The most reliable way of getting P.Shrimp to like and go after Aiptasia is to first place the shrimp in a tank where Aiptasia are the only food available. MSM in Centerville keeps theirs in a separate tank where rocks with Aiptasia are periodically offered. You can do the same in a bucket for a day with a rock of Aiptasia. Definitely feed the tank well prior to adding the P.Shrimp and starve it for a few days after.
3 All Shrimp are especially susceptible to improper acclimation procedures. FYI, acclimation is not for temperature, it's mainly for adjusting them to salinity and pH and their exoskeleton creates a need for extra special care both in physical handling and acclimation. For some reason they are more sensitive than another familiar organism with an exoskeleton, the crab. Shrimp are best acclimated slowly in an opaque container. Take at least 30 minutes to change 1/2-3/4 of the water in the waiting container before adding them to the tank, but do not leave them in the container for more than ~45 minutes. Drip acclimation is not necessary. Slow transfer of water a half cup at a time works well. Do not float them in a bag in the tank. They are hiders. Floating in open water is extremely stressful to them. When ready, set their waiting container slowly down into the water letting it fill slowly and move the container near the rocks so the Shrimp can quickly run over to the rock in the protection of the container without having to swim through open water.
4- Shrimp are very prone to heart attack. The stress which causes heart attack can be brought on just by being alone. It can also be caused by moving to a place where they do not know the hiding places. Introducing them to the tank in the dark or moonlight has definite advantages. I suggest buying three, even if you only need one. The chances are one will die, which leaves you with two and they really do best in groups, though one surviving Shrimp can live a long time in a Nano. I would definitely consider keeping at least two P.Shrimp per 50 gallons and that means buying three or four. (FYI, I suggest the same for Clownfish who also seem to have a similar mortality rate.)
5- Ideal living conditions are slightly different for shrimp than for fish. Shrimp are, after all, invertebrates. This means they are more susceptible to N compounds. Additionally, their exoskeleton creates unique needs and problems, like the need for protection after molting and the need for proper Alk, Ca, Mg, Strontium and other trace elements in the water to provide the abundance of minerals to grow new exoskeleton every 2-6 months.
I'm sure there is more, but that's all that would come out of my head this late at night.
As an interesting side note, Peppermint shrimp are in a group of animals that are simultaneous hermaphrodites, meaning that they can be male on one day and female on the other. The details are in an article in an old WMAS Sea Star Newsletter. Here is the link to that newsletter: http://www.utahreefs.com/SeaStar/wmasSeaStarOc00.pdf
Enjoy and good night.
Edited by Mark Peterson - May 13 2010 at 12:29am
|
Reefkeeping Tips, & quick, easy setup tricks:www.utahreefs.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9244 Pay it forward - become a paid WMAS member
|
|
Mark Peterson
Paid Member
Joined: June 19 2002
Location: Murray
Status: Offline
Points: 21436
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: April 25 2016 at 5:12pm |
Here is something else really cool and useful about Peppermint Shrimp(PS). It's kind of an addendum to item #2 above. They can be enticed to eat Aiptasia by killing some aiptasia. I had acquired ~100 lbs. of LR that was covered with Aiptasia. There were literally hundreds of Aiptasia. Even though the rock was placed in a bare aquarium with no other animals, no feeding, just a pump for circulation, the PS seemed to ignore the Aiptasia. After two weeks I had to try something. I killed about 5 Aiptasia with Kalkwasser paste, my preferred manual treatment method. Then I waited and watched. Just 7 days later the Aiptasia were no more. I guess the PS just needed to get an idea of how good the Aiptasia tasted by eating some dead ones. Then they feasted for a week of nights. Aloha, Mark
Edited by Mark Peterson - April 25 2016 at 5:16pm
|
Reefkeeping Tips, & quick, easy setup tricks:www.utahreefs.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9244 Pay it forward - become a paid WMAS member
|
|
Adam Blundell
Presidency
Joined: June 24 2002
Location: Davis County
Status: Offline
Points: 18526
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: April 25 2016 at 6:22pm |
I love butterflies. I'd still go that route. I'm thinking of adding more to my tank.
As for Aiptasia... filefish have sure become popular.
Adam
|
Come to a meeting, they’re fun!
|
|
Shane H
Presidency
Joined: March 09 2003
Location: Brigham City
Status: Offline
Points: 7921
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: April 26 2016 at 9:47pm |
Of the things you've listed in your tank, my guess is aiptasia will be the last thing a butterfly would eat. I love them, but they are not reef safe. Unless you have a huge tank with so much coral that you won't notice what the butterflies eat!
I'm also a fan of peppermint shrimp BTW.
|
|
Jeremyw
Guest
Joined: April 09 2009
Location: Utah County
Status: Offline
Points: 8513
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: April 27 2016 at 8:30am |
I would do peppermint shrimp, molly miller blenny or butterfly.
|
|
catchoftheday
Guest
Joined: September 01 2014
Location: Saratoga Spring
Status: Offline
Points: 521
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: April 27 2016 at 10:01am |
Jeremyw wrote:
I would do peppermint shrimp, molly miller blenny or butterfly. | Agree with what Jeremy has said I have both a Molly Miller and peppermint shrimp And I have no pest anemones at all I got mine from a reef oasis Shaun knows his stuff when it comes to the peppermint just an FYI
|
I currently have a 24 gallon JBJ all in one tank has two powerheads a phosphate reactor with the small bubble skimmer it is also powered by 2 X165 W LEDs and as a mixed reef
|
|
Jeremyw
Guest
Joined: April 09 2009
Location: Utah County
Status: Offline
Points: 8513
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: April 27 2016 at 11:59am |
I have a few molly millers and peppermints and they cleaned up my issue with Aiptasia! Only took about a week once I got all of them in. Got mine from Shaun as well!
|
|